A large customer can give a supplier enough work to justify a new production line. It can also leave the supplier with a factory full of equipment that is hard to put to another use. The investment case depends on what the customer has agreed to buy and how much of the initial investment the supplier still has to recover through future orders.
The example below shows why the same drop in orders can cost one supplier far more than another.
How much has the customer committed to buy?
Months before the first shipment, a supplier may have to secure equipment, hire staff and qualify the production line with its customer. A volume forecast can help it decide how much capacity to build. The financial protection comes from the purchase commitments and cancellation terms it has secured.
Even a multiyear agreement can leave room for volumes to change. One contract might specify a minimum number of units or a payment if the customer buys less than agreed. Another might set prices and delivery terms while leaving order quantities open. A customer contribution towards tooling can reduce the supplier’s upfront investment, while ownership of the tooling helps determine whether it can be used for other orders later.
Financial statements can reveal some of the exposure. Customer concentration disclosures can show how much of last year’s revenue came from a major account(s). Capital expenditure and depreciation give a sense of the investment involved, although the figures may cover several production lines. Where the contract terms are undisclosed, investors can model a fall in orders under different assumptions about compensation and see how much the valuation changes.
Two suppliers with the same customer exposure
In this hypothetical example, two manufacturers each generate £500m in annual revenue and earn 40% of their sales from their largest customer. Both have expanded capacity to serve that account. The customer then cuts its annual orders by a quarter, taking £50m of sales out of each supplier before contractual payments or replacement orders.
The first supplier uses equipment that can serve other customers after a few months of adjustment and qualification. It also has an agreement that entitles it to a payment if purchases fall below a specified minimum. Assume it receives £5m under that agreement and replaces half the lost sales within the year.
Qualifying the second supplier’s dedicated line for another customer would take more than a year. It has no minimum purchase commitment. While the factory is underused, it still has to maintain the equipment and retain some of the skilled staff it would need if orders picked up.
|
Illustrative first-year impact |
First supplier |
Second supplier |
|
Sales lost from the largest customer |
£50m |
£50m |
|
Replacement sales to other customers |
£25m |
£0 |
|
Payment under minimum purchase agreement |
£5m |
£0 |
|
Estimated reduction in operating profit |
£2.5m |
£15m |
In this example, each £1 of sales carries 70p in variable costs, leaving 30p to cover fixed costs and contribute to profit. Fixed costs stay the same, so every £1 of sales lost cuts operating profit by 30p, and every £1 of replacement sales adds 30p. The £5m payment counts towards first-year operating profit, and neither supplier incurs extra retooling costs that year.
Lower prices on replacement orders could reduce the profit recovered. If a new customer needs more time to test samples and approve the production line, the supplier may also have to wait longer for regular orders.
What happens when the contract comes up for renewal?
A customer may keep buying the same volume and still seek a lower price. Once a supplier has installed dedicated machinery, accepting thinner margins may look better than leaving the line idle. The customer may have reasons to stay, too. Moving production could require testing a new line and accepting a period of lower output while another supplier gets up to speed.
The timing of the next negotiation matters particularly when the equipment is due for replacement. The supplier may need to order new machinery before it knows what price the customer will pay under the next agreement. If there is scope to defer that spending until terms are settled, the supplier has more room to negotiate.
Large accounts can also improve a factory’s economics. Reliable volumes keep equipment busy, give production teams more opportunity to improve yields and spread engineering costs over more units. The value of those benefits depends partly on how much of the investment the supplier can recover before the terms come up for renewal.
What are investors paying for?
The first supplier takes a £2.5m hit to operating profit in year one, compared with £15m for the second. For valuation, how long those shortfalls last matters as much as their initial size. Suppose the first supplier’s £5m payment applies only in year one and replacement sales stay at £25m. On the same margin assumptions, the annual operating profit shortfall would widen from £2.5m to £7.5m once the payment ends. Investors would then need to judge whether replacement orders could grow and what margins the supplier could earn on them.
For the second supplier, the £15m shortfall could narrow once the line is qualified for another customer. The value of that recovery depends on how soon shipments can start and how much cash the supplier must spend adapting the equipment. Even if both manufacturers eventually restore their previous earnings, a longer wait and a larger upfront investment reduce the present value of that recovery.
Those assumptions belong in the cash-flow forecast. Model the contractual payment for the period it covers, allow for the cash spent adapting the line, and reflect the margins likely to apply at renewal. Two suppliers can enter the year with the same customer exposure and finish it with very different prospects for recovering the money they put into the factory.
